4 ways Controller Hardware in the Loop and Model-based Engineering are Reducing Risk

May 10, 2019
Typhoon HIL leaders break down how Controller Hardware in the Loop (C-HIL), and model-based engineering work to ensure your microgrid performs, and allows companies to test and validate microgrid design every step of the way.

Matt Baker, Ivan Celanovic and Paul Roege, of Typhoon-HIL, break down how Controller Hardware in the Loop (C-HIL), and model-based engineering work to ensure your microgrid performs, and allows companies to test and validate microgrid design every step of the way.

Industry 4.0 is dawning, and digitalization, decarbonization, and decentralization (aka D3) are fueling the electric grid (r)evolution.  D3, in turn, creates opportunities for immense value creation, but invokes new technologies and design concepts, and change brings risk.

The emerging cyber-physical grid — with proliferating distributed energy resources (PV, wind, gensets, batteries, etc.); embedded controllers; intelligent sensors; communication links; large data; multilayered distributed digital control; and cloud software — is forcing industry leaders to embrace new design, test, deployment and lifecycle maintenance tools and processes.

Twentieth century power systems incorporated the physics of electromechanical systems – dominated by inductive generators, motors and transformers – which eventually grew into the synchronized grid that has been called the world’s largest machine.  Cyber-physical systems bring not only dramatic increases in data, but fundamentally different power devices.  The inverters, power converters and motor drives that are being installed in homes, infrastructure and factories today utilize rapid digital electronic power switching to manipulate currents, voltages, frequency and other attributes as needed.  Their flexibility delivers a dramatic increase in possible system behaviors and interactions that cannot be adequately analyzed with classical engineering tools. Model based methods, such as Controller Hardware in the Loop (C-HIL) tools, are beginning to supercharge power electronics and microgrid design and deployment processes.

HIL testing has been a standard in the aerospace industry for decades; from testing jet engine controller units, all the way to the autopilot.  The safety criticality of airplane control systems set the bar high in terms of control software development, test, and maintenance processes. For example,no jet engine controller gets flight certified without an extensive record of HIL testing, in addition to regular laboratory testing and a significant number of flight hours. HIL testing has become a ubiquitous tool to maximize test coverage, reduce per testcost, and achieve requisite reliability in aerospace.

As high-performance modeling and simulations tools become more affordable, microgrids stand next in line. Most equipment vendors have adopted HIL testing, and microgrid system integrators are beginning to use its extensive testing and validation capability to characterize and validate microgrid control system performance, integrated with DER’s and smart devices, to assure performance, reliability, and cybersecurity. A HIL Tested environment provides the ability to virtually test firmware and software in a safe, repeatable and systematic way as the system is being developed, rather than waiting until after startup.

Here are four ways Controller Hardware in the Loop (C-HIL) and model-based engineering can reduce the risk during design, deployment and operation of your microgrid:

1.  Manage control complexity and guarantee interoperability

Over the past 30 years, embedded systems have undergone exponential growth in control code complexity as measured by number of source lines of code (SLOC) [2].  To illustrate this trend, consider three examples:

  1. F-35 fighter plane code grew from 6.8M (SLOC) in 2006 to 24M (SLOC) in 2013
  2. Automobile (high end): from 2M (SLOC) in 2000 to 100M (SLOC) in 2018
  3. PV inverter: from 0.05M (SLOC) to 0.2 (SLOC) in 2018

As smart inverters and other cyber-physical components grow in sophistication, their programming complexity climbs a similar exponential curve. Even today, a typical microgrid with 10 smart inverters, 10 protective relays and one microgrid controller can easily reach 5 million lines of combined SLOC.  When we network hundreds of microgrids in virtual power plants or similar system architectures, we will soon reach scales that exceed a billion SLOC.

(image: Typhoon HIL)

Indeed, the exponential increase in code base will transform microgrids and utilities into truly flexible, multifunctional, and adaptive (resilient) cyber-physical systems. Clearly, we need the right tools and processes to support and accelerate this transformation.

“Increasing test coverage and reducing your development times without compromising the quality of the firmware are quality aspects that we feel HIL tested would add to our portfolio of products.” Sau Ngosi, CTO Residential Solar & Storage, Schneider Electric

How does one maintain and improve microgrid control software quality while managing exponential growth in complexity? It is simple, but not easy. The aerospace and automotive industries have demonstrated the value of religious Hardware in the Loop, model based testing; continuous integration (CI) software development processes; broadly-based development testing; and test automation. VDC Research results show 38% reduction in number of software bugs when Controller Hardware in the Loop (C-HIL) is used early on in the design process and throughout the lifecycle, including a 60% reduction in the cost of fixing bugs when embedded software is developed and tested using C-HIL methodology.

2.  Reduce time to market and innovate with confidence.

Traditionally, power electronics and power systems industries have been slow to introduce new products and new functionalities. Limited lab testing and operational field experience provided the only feedback; mistakes were costly.  The approach “if it works don’t change anything” led to product design cycles of 5+ years, and product lifecycles could be greater than 25 years.

HIL Testing is flipping this paradigm upside down and is empowering developers to continuously improve and integrate new functionalities by easily adding new software functions. As product changes and upgrades increasingly become software-based, better code processes can accelerate innovation. Consider the example of a Tesla car.  With remote updates, the owner often wakes up to a different car in the morning – one with new functionality and better performance.  In the future, microgrids will be upgraded and improved in the same way, with new software that was thoroughly tested using C-HIL testbed under tens of thousands of test scenarios.

 “Our system integrator Raytheonextensively used a Controller Hardware in the Loop (C-HIL) testbed during the design and development phases, before the Microgrid was even built, to test and validate a spectrum of operational scenarios (including fault conditions).  This significantly reduced interoperability risk.” Shawn Doyle, Otis Air National Guard Base, Massachusetts

Otis Air National Guard Base (ANGB) Microgrid. DoD’s first cybersecure controller with outside connection and the first wind based DoD’s microgrid was tested and validated with Typhoon HIL’s ultra-high fidelity C-HIL testbed. (Photo: Typhoon HIL)

3.  Empower system integrators

Today, most of microgrid projects are brownfield, or modifications to existing infrastructure. Brownfield projects require system integrators to gracefully orchestrate old and new equipment, interfacing new control and communication infrastructure with existing assets; upgrading existing DERs; and integrating new microgrid controllers with the distribution system operation.

“We will provide the model of our system, and then other people — the third-party, our customers; in this case, for example, a system-integrator — would use […] our model integrated into their system model, so now they can simulate the entire system.” – Nicolas LaRue, Global Offer Manager, Schneider Electric

C-HIL and model based engineering enables system integrators to prototype the composite system with full fidelity, early on in the design phase, and use the developed model to test and validate microgrid design every step of the way.

“One of the things that we’ve been doing recently that might change our future development path, is how HIL is starting to change our relationships with our customers. We are supplying or providing access to the Hardware-in-the-Loop system to some of our customers, and that’s helping them understand the operation of the inverter better and allows them to answer some of their own questions about capabilities and operational sequencing and things like that.” – Ryan Smith, CTO, EPC Power

4.  Supercharge life-cycle maintenance with C-HIL digital twin

Much of today’s focus is on winning the project, followed by design and commissioning. Like all infrastructure, however, microgrid lifecycle operation and maintenance is of critical importance to investors, users, and operators, but is rarely given serious consideration up front.  A C-HIL testbed, or a very high-fidelity microgrid digital twin, can provide an opportune environment to:

  • seamlessly test firmware and software upgrades to smart devices and microgrid controllers before deployment;
  • model and simulate anomalies that may be anticipated or discovered during operation, and to test fixes;
  • test equipment upgrades and any interoperability issues that might arise prior to deployment;

Indeed, a C-HIL testbed provides a high-fidelity model of the as-built microgrid that can be maintained and upgraded as the microgrid evolves.

“Our project will require testing and refinement overtime.  Even now, as we prepare for commissioning, we are anticipating micro outages and frequency anomalies in the grid that might “upset” our system controller.  Having the digital twin in the form of the C-HIL testbed will enable recreating these events in C-HIL digital twin and trouble shooting and optimizing these issues without the concern of damaging equipment or having outages onsite.” — Shawn Doyle, Otis Air National Guard Base, Massachusetts

This represents the new standard for risk reduction in Twenty-first Century power system development and maintenance.

A version of this guest article originally ran on the Typhoon-HIL Blog.

Matt Baker is director for microgrids and critical power at Typhoon-HIL. 

Paul Roege is vice president for strategic initiatives at Typhoon HIL. 

Ivan Celanovic is chief business development officer and co-founder of Typhoon-HIL. 

Join Typhoon-HIL for a discussion, ” Making Sure Your Microgrid Will Work: Risk Reduction with Controller Hardware in the Loop and Model Based Engineering,” at Microgrid 2019 in San Diego May 14.

About the Author

Guest Post

Only through Standardization Can Microgrids Accelerate the Energy Transition

Jan. 18, 2024
Jana Gerber, North America microgrid president at Schneider Electric discusses how standardizing microgrids will accelerate the energy transition.

Get the full report

Impact of Optimal Controls in a Microgrid

Many commercial and industrial businesses are installing microgrids in order to lower their energy costs, reduce their carbon emissions, and bolster their resilience. Learn how...